So here we all are.
In the newsroom, in j-school, in our little corner of the blogosphere, producing great journalism, training great journalism students, and pointing out fantastic examples of both to each other and our peers, doing our best to make the transition to online news.
We forgot to bring the advertising department to the party.
Yeah, sure, as journalists, it’s not really our job to figure out how to monetize this stuff.
That’s what we tell ourselves as we post our multimedia projects without templates that include ad positions. That’s what we tell ourselves while print revenue declines — and online doesn’t grow anywhere near fast enough to make up for it.
Alright, so without going too far into whether journalists are supposed to be thinking about this or not, here are five ways to improve online advertising revenue at your newspapaper.com. (How’s that for burying the lede?)
- Embrace contextual advertising: Make AdSense your friend. Spread a little around your article pages: It’s like free money falling from the sky and not nearly as annoying to your users as giant Flash banners. And it loads faster.
- Go big, cut down on ad positions, and charge more for display ads: Let advertisers feel like they are buying a full page print ad opposite your content. Use giant 300xwhatever skyscrapers that are practically like a sponsorship for the page, and let that be the only display ad on the page. Charge far more for that exclusive spot, and sell it to your big full-page type clients.
- Target affiliate programs to relevant pages: Do I want to sign up for Netflix while I’m reading a crime story? Maybe not, but sell me on iTunes and Netflix from your music and movie review pages, and maybe I’ll bite. That goes double for travel site ads on your travel pages. The near future of affiliate ads is widget-based ads where your users will be able to sign up for a service or buy a product without leaving your page. Keep it relevant and your conversion rate should only go up.
- Sell more than eyeballs: The page view is dead, but the CPM model of online ad sells lives. That can’t be right, right? Find something to sell to your clients: Relevance, demographics, most popular stories and sections, a chunk of syndicated/wire content that is a huge hit in your town. Dig into the numbers and make something work.
- Party together: If your ad sales staff doesn’t know what ad positions are available online, or doesn’t pay enough attention to the news site to know what lots of people are looking at without seeing local advertising, you need to get together, form a committee, have some meetings, and just generally talk to each other. Even if your desk is in the newsroom. Seriously, this isn’t going to work unless the smartest people in the building sit down together and make it happen. If you really think your journalism is going to be affected by letting the ad department know there’s room for a 5-second preroll ad position on all that video you’re shooting, you might be in the wrong business.
So now it’s your turn, of course. What’s the smartest bit of online advertising you’ve seen at a newspaper.com lately — or better yet — what’s the smartest thing going on in online ads anywhere right now that you think we should let our sales staffs know about?
Further reading: Scott Karp’s been all over this territory recently. Start here, and work your way into it.
5 thoughts on “The innovation gap: Your advertising department could use a hand”
[…] The innovation gap: Your advertising department could use a hand. Ryan Sholin says it’s time to get involved the folks in the ad department if you want to make this online thing work. […]
[…] Invisible Inkling: The innovation gap: Your advertising department could use a hand Ryan Sholin says journalists are getting the Internet: “One problem. We forgot to bring the advertising department to the party.” (tags: advertising online internet journalism) […]
I agree with everything you’ve said here. One clarification: Google’s AdSense isn’t going to make anyone loads of money, at least not the way it works now. Very low CPM rates.
It’s easy money, yes. It’s also not without consequence.
I have two opposing thoughts about AdSense. The first is that AdSense is designed to trick newspapers into letting Google develop a relationship with our advertisers, and that we should never lose that advantage to anyone. The second is if we can’t beat ’em, join ’em. Embrace Google’s idea even more by selling all the inventory across the whole site using Google’s AdSense. Scrap all efforts to sell local banner. Instead, spend time selling other things.
I guess “easy money” is never as simple as it first appears.
In other news, I agree with what you’re saying about raising CPM rates on banner ads.
[…] Sholin listed ways to get online advertising to catch up to the online content that journalists are beginning to produce. I tend to disagree that online […]
[…] Invisible Inkling » The innovation gap: Your advertising department could use a hand We forgot to bring the advertising department to the party. (tags: newspapers) […]
Comments are closed.